Discussion about this post

User's avatar
TW52's avatar

Here's what's missing from this commentary. Why do Democrats want to regain power? What policies will/should they promote? What is it that they want to accomplish if given 4 years? How would that differ from their policies during the past 4 years when they had power? How would that differ from core Republican ideology today, in areas such as immigration, energy, education, the economy, federalism, etc? Saying that Democrats need to "reconnect with the working class" is a demographic conclusion. The question is, what policies will Democrats promote that will convince the working class to leave their recent shift toward Republicans? I have a hard time seeing how Democrats can successfully do this. A majority of the voting public favor the central policies and principles of the Republican party: less intrusive government; deregulation to promote economic growth through free market capitalism; retrenchment from onerous environmental and climate change regulations toward an "all-of-the-above" energy approach; greater school choice; safer communities through enhancement of community police and elimination of recent criminal justice decriminalization and bail reforms; devolution of power to state and local communities, etc. Democrats, on the other hand, are the party of robust government action. They are the party that advocates centralized power across national agencies to advance their economic and cultural agenda. How does a political party whose ideology is oriented around government solutions attract a working majority after the wide-spread aversion to big government during the Biden administration? Once you get to specifics, the approach Ruy advocates is essentially "conservative lite" without details. It's tactical, simply to win elections. But to do what?

Expand full comment
Dale McConnaughay's avatar

For a Democrat to win the presidency in 2028, he or she is going to have to spend less time and effort compromising and currying favor for the Party's out-of-touch progressive Left wing and more gaining a foothold with Independents and centist Republicans who never liked or have tired of Trump, especially if the GOP continues to lose ground on the economy and other bread-and-butter issues.

Expand full comment
26 more comments...

No posts